MLG Disqualifies Dignitas and Curse During Summer Championship


Written by: (Twitter @Ruleof3z - ) | August 28, 2012 4:33 pm

MLG Disqualifies Dignitas and Curse During Summer Championship
6 Comments

This past weekend saw some amazing matches as 12 teams competed for the MLG Summer Championship title.  Crucial circuit points that would directly effect participation in the PAX Regional this coming weekend were at stake, and it was a weekend full of close matches, upset victories, and tons of action.

Unfortunately, all of this was eclipsed on the last day of the tournament when both Team Dignitas and Curse Gaming were disqualified in the championship match.

The reason?

After thorough investigation, MLG representatives discovered that the two teams had colluded with one another to split the 1st and 2nd place prize money.  Starting the first round of the match with an ARAM sure didn’t help convince people they were actually playing competitively during the finals.  And as the MLG Pro Circuit Conduct Rules clearly state, ““competitors may not intentionally Forfeit a Game or conspire to manipulate Rankings or Brackets.”  VP of eSports Redbeard confirmed Riot’s agreement with the decision.

What does this all mean?

For starters, neither Dignitas nor Curse were awarded any circuit points for the competition.  While both teams had already qualified for PAX, Dignitas’ hope of taking the 2nd seed and a more favorable match-up from CLG.NA heading into this weekend was destroyed.  Instead, they’re now all but sure to face Team Dynamic in their first round at PAX – a team that has given them problems in the past.

Perhaps even worse, though, is the backlash this has on Curse.  In a truly amazing display of perserverance, Curse had actually come back to defeat Dignitas in the last 3 games of the best of 5.  Forever seen as the dark horse – a team noteworthy for their skill but never quite able to finish – this was actually the first major tournament Curse had won in either the NA or EU scene.  And while it is my personal belief that a trophy isn’t necessary to proclaim how good a team is, defeating Dignitas to become the official MLG Summer Champions surely would have legitimized Curse as a team to be reckoned with among their naysayers.

Following these events, Curse released an official statement to their fans and the eSports community.  For what it’s worth, both teams apologized and agreed with the final decisions.  As SVP of MLG Lee Chan best summarized, “We’re all trying to build eSports into something bigger and professional. Riot, MLG and all the teams. There’s no way that matchfixing is ok”.

While this may go down as a negative blemish to LoL eSports, it should in no way cheapen the exciting matches that took place this past weekend.  Be sure to catch all the replays on the  VOD from MLG’s website this week.

Was this the right call?  Should there be a greater punishment?  Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!


  • christopher murray

    In real professional sports, if you fix games you are banned for life from the sport.  If mlg and riot want this to be considered a real sport in the future they need real sport punishments.  It doesnt matter that they are great players, like it didnt matter that shoeless joe jackson still played great but still took the money in the blacksox 1919 world series.

    • http://twitter.com/tamgros Matthew Sorg

      They didn’t throw the game or fix the games, they just split the prize money. If you notice, Dignitas was the only team to have something to gain by winning, winning assured them 2nd. So if the games really were fixed, Dignitas would have won. This was more “this game doesn’t matter as much as the regional finals, so we’re not going to show everyone our best stuff… let’s play an ARAM”.

      Similar things happen all the time in pro sports where at the end of seasons when teams have already made the playoffs, they don’t try to win. Hell, in some sports teams TRY to lose to get better draft picks. People view that as totally legit. The only problem here is the collusion aspect, but again, they didn’t collude on who would win, just the prize payout (which is disputed by Curse btw, they say they only colluded to have fun and play an ARAM).

      Among offenses, even colluding to split prize money isn’t on the same level as colluding for who wins. Teams under the same banner, CLG.NA vs CLG.EU for example, split some of the prize money as it is. Even though these teams aren’t in the same organization, honestly to me it was semi sporting what they were trying to do, it just happened to be against the rules. Not that I totally disagree with punishing the teams. But, it’s also of MLG’s fault for having a semi meaningless tournament a week before the largest tournament of the year. So the punishment was fitting.

      • http://twitter.com/Ruleof3z John Mills

        One of the common arguments against the punishment was actually if it would have been such a big deal if they weren’t heard discussing it in public. 

        That is, what would the reaction be if neither team necessarily planned to lose (which arguably didn’t happen to begin with) but still split the prize money after the fact?  The tournament ends, 1st and 2nd place are crowned, and the next day we hear Curse and Dignitas decided to share the money.  Would it still be bad?

        It is interesting to see MLG’s thought process nonetheless.  I wonder how it would have all be handled under that scenario.

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=502603000 Jeremy Rodriguez

        I think the bigger problem is all the work Riot is putting into trying to take e-sports to a new level. They’re trying to legitimize it and lay the foundation for it being a more mainstream spectator sport, as well as e-sports in general. I don’t think rationalizing it by saying other sports do the same kind of shiftyness is a valid argument. They are already legitimate sports.

        In any competitive sport (and especially during tournaments) you expect the players to perform to their highest degree possible. Sure ARAM is fun, but it’s not condusive to competitive e-sports. I’m not saying this “corruption” should or shouldn’t happen, I just agree with the decision to disqualify them.

        As far as splitting prize money is concerned, I don’t really care what they do with their winnings. But whatever deals they make behind the scenes better not effect how hard they try to win a game.

        Also, as a viewer, I don’t watch tournaments to see people dick around on ARAM, I can gather a bunch of buddies to do that. I came to see top-level play where every misclick can cost you the game.

  • Dertnapz

    The funny thing is, the ARAM was a hell of a lot more exciting than the normal games. It was funny to hear the casters trying to keep up with all the action.

    The interview that SaintVicious gave with MLG was pretty much how I would have reacted.

    MLG: “Do you guys think this is a game? Did you have fun?”

    SaintVicious “Well it is a game. We were trying to have fun. That’s the reason I play games. WHATEVER!” /shrug

    Dignitas was in the position to throw the game and set up their seeding regardless of whether or not the prize was split. If MLG wanted to avoid that then they would change the way the circuit works.

  • DoctorOverlord

    First Olympic badminton fixing matches now professional video gamers!  

    It’s an epidemic!  

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
Monday
6 pst

The Republic

Star Wars The Old Republic

Tuesday
n/a

Monty's Minute

Have Questions? He Has Answers

9 pst

After Dark

Live Call In Show

Wednesday
6 pst

Guildcast

Guild Wars 2

Thursday
7 pst

Conspiracy Craft

World of WarCraft Lore

8 pst

Legendary

World of WarCraft

Friday
3 pst

TWIMMO

This Week In MMO

4 pst

Derpy Dragon

Free to Play Show



TOP GAMES
Guild Wars 2 MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Arenanet
Metacritic Score: 90
The Elder Scrolls Online MMORPG News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Zenimax
Metacritic Score: n/a
World of Warcraft MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Blizzard
Metacritic Score: 82
SWTOR MMO News
Genre: MMORPG SciFi
Developer: Bioware
Metacritic Score: 85
League of Legends News
Genre: MOBA
Developer: Riot
Metacritic Score: 78