Senator Alexander: Video Games "Bigger Problem Than Guns"

Written by: (@JuhTai) | January 30, 2013 1:02 pm

49 Comments

Republican Senator Alexander claims video games “a bigger problem than guns”

If I was the type that takes conspiracy theories seriously, I’d be inclined to start believing that somebody has been tampering with the water supply of some of the US Senators.

Yesterday, news hit the headlines when California Senator Leland Yee felt the need to tell gamers to “Quiet down” after weeks of protest from gamers over the topic of violent video games that has been a constant talking point since the tragic Connecticut school massacre, just over a month ago.

Although he has since apologized for his comment, it hasn’t dettered another challenger from entering the fray. Que; Republican Senator Lamar Alexander.

Speaking earlier today on MSNBC’s, The Daily Rundown, Senator Alexander told host Chuck Todd that he felt video games are a much bigger problem than guns.

I think video games is a bigger problem than guns” he continued on to say “Because video games affect people. But the First Amendment limits what we can do about video games and the Second Amendment to the constitution limits what we can do about guns.”

It seems like this is a topic that government officials truly are not going to let go of, with the blame being forced more and more on to the industry that we all know and love.

So what is your opinion? Are video games really to blame for violent crime? Does Senator Alexander make a valid point? Is this really the right way to go about things? We love to hear your opinions, so hit us up in the comment box below!
Senator Alexander: Video Games "Bigger Problem Than Guns"

  • http://www.facebook.com/jonathan.hornsby.7 Jonathan Hornsby

    First it was comics, then it was heavy metal, then movies and tv, and now it is video games. These guys don’t want to acknowledge the real problem because it would offend what they consider “the wrong people.” They don’t mind using us as a scapegoat because they don’t think we make up a large enough percentage of American voters, so they don’t care if they offend and alienate us. Perhaps it is time we remind them how big our community is. Perhaps we should organize and have a little demonstration to protect our constitutional rights for a change.

  • Rodrigo Gomez

    I will explain this fast then : 0-How easy is to obtain fire-weapons creates a lot crimes in witch fire weapons are used
    1-Guns generate more money than games
    2-Guns manufacturers put money in campaigns
    3-a Politicians wont bite the hand that feeds them 
    3-b Politicians loves moneyTherefore if problem created by gun manufacturers selling weapons. Translate the problem to something the monkeys can believe

    • http://twitter.com/dularr Dularr

      Nope. Guns do not create crimes, that is ludicrous   Criminals commit crimes.  Is gun violence tragic, sure it is. But I think it points to serious problems with our society, family, the media, mental health services and school systems. 

      We are citizens protecting our rights for home defense, shooting sports and hunting. 

      Do I think gun manufactures lobby politicians, of course they do.  They lobby to protect themselves from frivolous lawsuits.  

      I do not think video games cause violence. Parents need to be in control of what their children play.

      • http://www.facebook.com/blake.williams.5876 Blake Williams

        Here is the thing, America has the most crimes involving a firearm above all other counties, but it doesn’t have the highest crime rate per-capita. It was said in other comments, guns are a tool for crime just like a hammer is a tool for building. The fact of the matter is that if you took away all guns, all that would change is the tool used to commit the crime. More criminals would fall back to knives or large blunt weapons (like a hammer). If knives become the weapon of choice then would we ban all knives? A gun is simply a tool made specifically for killing, it’s no worse than a bow & arrow or mini-crossbow in that sense, it’s just a matter of what we use the gun to kill.

      • Rodrigo Gomez

        im not saying you stop selling guns. What i say is that maybe making it a little harder to obtain one. And not making weapons accesible to every looney in town for how much 300 bucks ? 

  • http://www.facebook.com/Zeazin Craig Leon-Barr Milne

     I agree because you can throw the discs of your violent video games like shurikens and kill innocent people. This shouldn’t be allowed.

  • http://www.facebook.com/fredrik.gardsio Fredrik Fronken Gardsiö

    The amount of stupid in the american political system continues to amaze me.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Filip-Buhov/1379207683 Filip Buhov

    guns don’t kill people , my razer naga does

  • Torguish

    So.. guns don’t effect people? I mean, the gun used in those shootings were affected by video games more than guns? Really? Not the fact that the shooters were on anti-depressants which cause anxiety, suicide and aggression? None of that?

    This tool should quit existing.

  • http://twitter.com/Mark_D_O Mark David Outhwaite

    Hmmm it’s amusing how completely out of touch Politicians can end up being, I’m of the Nes generation, and from my time at Uni etc I can probably name 2-3 girls and 1-2 guys who’ve never played video games that I know. The generations after me, the numbers have got to be even more rare .. all these Politicians are saying to anyone under 50 or anyone more tech progressive who is older is .. “I’m stupid and or corrupt, don’t vote for me”.  They’ve missed the boat, and will be remembered in the same vain as the morons who drown women as witches, or hunted down Communists, or burned books. 

    If EA had they lobbying machine behind it that the NRA has this wouldn’t even be being discussed they’d blame it on sugar intake or something else as inane, but the GOP in general aren’t interested in facts, it’s all about the cash. Fear-mongering propaganda merchants, it just doesn’t hold up to a generation who has been born into the information age.

    We each have at our fingertips all the information we could ever need, and by this time an almost innate knowledge on how access it. Our google-fu is strong, and the line you’re feeding us is weak sauce. Only the Fox News watching wilfully ignorant buy this crap.

    • http://www.facebook.com/chris.collins.5059601 Chris Collins

      stop spouting your GOP hating mantra and your “Fox news” talking points. Senator Yee is a Democrat. the problem isnt left or right, the problem is a handful of people in power that believe they know whats good for you because you’re to stupid to know better. even though they are more cluless than the constituants that they look down upon. people like yourself and people on the right that blindly folow the ideology their party of prefrence instead of thinking with a little common sense is why these idiots in government keep getting elected and/or relected.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mark-T-Russell/667898328 Mark T. Russell

    The point here is that neither guns nor video games are to blame for violence. I have to wonder why either would be blamed for the actions of a homicidal maniac? Clearly guns were the tool used, but the gun itself is no more responsible for the crime as a hammer is responsible for the house being built down the street. One could argue that violent video games and movies are a reflection of our culture, but there is no evidence to support the idea that a video game makes a person act out violently in the real world.

  • http://www.facebook.com/austin.g.boyd Austin Grant Boyd

    I always thought video games helped people in a positive way and helped them blow off steam =/

  • Anthony Gudmundsson

    Listening to this guy really infuriates me. So over politicians using video games as a scape-goat.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jesse-Hyde/843505595 Jesse Hyde

    his ignorance is frustrating, he should stick to what he knows, and that is not it, haha.

  • http://www.facebook.com/inkogni.alex Inkogni Alex

    some one needs to come to that man and first show him a shooter gun in one hand and see hes reaction THEN show a gun ( DON’T SHOOT THE IDIOT ) in other and guess what. you got him pissing pants, calling for mommy/security and what not.

  • Kaemin

    That was a joke right? rightttt????? He proposed a opinion as fact with no data to enforce this statement it would be like me saying milk causes brain tumors. 

  • http://twitter.com/ToriMcGrath Tori McGrath

    I’m sorry but what an idiot. 

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ian-Smith/100000531128393 Ian Smith

       I’m sorry I had to hear the idiot speak.  ;)

  • http://www.facebook.com/TechCamacho David Camacho

    He’s completely right… video games do affect people. Every time I get frustrated while playing video game I end up doing something violent in real life. Just the other day I was playing Ms. Pac Man and I just couldn’t get to the fruit in time to eat it so I got mad… I took it out on my neighbor by beating him to death with a cherry while yelling, “Hurry up and eat it! Clyde and Inky are coming!” Oh God I’m a monster… *Sobs*

  • theunwarshed

    video games are worse because they effect people?  someone, somewhere has to eventually do a mashup of all these lame public political statements for the lawls.

  • Kaemin

    On a side note did it seem like he was almost coached into saying that? Look at the way his arms move now clearly we can’t see his forearms or hands but they seem to be going in and out of a defensive posture, before he starts talking you can see him glance of to the side an indicator of rehearsed lines, someone knowing and feeling something comes off way different than someone just remembering what to say. 

  • http://twitter.com/cosmic_kirby CosmicKirby

    Senator claims: Humans are immune to guns, 

  • Raul Vergara

    wow ..i didn’t know video games kill people then GUNS ? HOLY things ya find out
    LOL

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=764144633 Christian Tomsheck

    But guns don’t affect people?  I can tell you, if I got shot to death it would affect me.  It would affect me a lot more than being shot in Call of Duty.

  • http://www.facebook.com/stuart.chafin Stuart Chafin

    What he meant to say was, “Your freedoms get in the way of us ruling over you with a iron fist, and we need to get as many of them pesky things away from you” 

     Just look at their successes, the censorship of comics through the silver age, the censorship of music with explicit music labels (early 90′s), the censorship of kids programing (FOR THE CHILDREN), and you have to look as this as a golden age. 

    Sic semper tyrannis – Thus always to tyrants (VA motto) – Homie don’t play that little senators.

  • donaldmratomic

    This senator and this message paid for by the gun lobby to distract you from the real problem.

  • http://twitter.com/RichardIRL Richard Elder

    I’m a gamer and a gun owner, as many Americans are. Most of us have no intention of ever shooting a human being. I highly value the First Amendment and Second Amendment which protect these freedoms for us. This senator and many of our legislators need to take another look at our Constitution and if they’re of the same opinion then their competency and reading comprehension is seriously lacking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kyle-Eggers/100000868131517 Kyle Eggers

    The problem isn’t guns or videos games.  The problem is that we are humans who are animals that like violence and are aggressive, mix in a few crazy one who don’t get any help from any one or organizations and then bad things will happen.  Are elected Senators, Representatives, and the President jobs are to protect our rights, not impose what they think is right or wrong with the going trend.  Educate and changing peoples attitude towards gun and human life, that would change more then any gun law and law against violence in the media (TV, movies, print, or video games).

  • ReAlIzEr

    Just a few thoughts and words:

    We can talk all day about amendments / Gun control / Violence in games / who controls who but, is any of our responses being communicated, (where they ALL must hear), to the people who need to hear and learn them?   Don’t let the voice go unheard and don’t let either side go out of control. Stick to common sense facts, and our own history of violence (before their where video games).The LARGE amount of date already collected about how the environment that surrounds us and that we create – both effects & affects us as a people and our characteristics individually, already has the proof we need to make an educated theory / guess / reason.I think it should be noted as a reminder that abnormalities do occur with no rhyme nor reason.

    BEWARE of the children, they can kick your butt both online and offline outside of video games.

    Maybe it is time to rethink (as adults) what kids really know via the world we have created for them and ourselves.

    you violent violent people you – grow and pair and grow up.

    • http://www.facebook.com/jonathan.ericson.39 Jonathan Ericson

       Please. Learn English.

  • http://www.facebook.com/jason.jenkins.73 Jason Jenkins

    in my simple uneducated nonpolitical mind is to simply enforce the age restrictions that are already on games, if a game is NC 17 simply make it illegal to sell it to minors and then actualy enforce that law like we do now with cigarettes and alchole.  stop this nonsense of banning games, or banning violent games and just put laws in place to help stem the sell to minors.  will it hurt the industry? you bet it will, but its better then leaving it to these guys who would ban everything out right for no other reason then to have a scape goat to blame other then guns.

  • Deacon1979

    Games affect people but guns don’t?!?

    Granted the end of walking dead did affect me, however temporarily. When guns affect people it tends to be more permanent.

  • http://twitter.com/Jumoped J L

    Ignorance is an even bigger problem 

  • ansamech

    I hope a buss full of kids playing videogames runs him over

  • http://www.facebook.com/james.walters.9028 James Walters

    *sigh* I swear, this is getting ignorant on a whole new level..  Nothing like politicians trying to cash in on a situation, Games didn’t cause any of this..  I mean seriously,  your really just gonna single out video games from generations of TV networks, the Movie & Music industries that have done it for years..  Then why not just punish all of entertainment as a whole? All I’m seeing from this so far is just more & more reasons for people not taking responsibility & for what there kids do..

  • William Dayan

    Kyle Eggers said it best, but I can understand senator close minded view, guns really don’t affect you on a mental level, as there just tools. Games on the other hand your interacting with , while I personaly think 99.9999999999999999% of the people can distinguish a game from the real would, there is that one crazy person that can’t. There is no logic reason for the Small chance of a crazy person who is most likely unstable to behind with, to limit our freedom, weather it’d be with playing video games, or owning guns. Crazy people will do crazy things its just the way of life in general weather it’d be a crazy dog, or person. ITS LIFE so start living in the real world, where bad people do bad things for no logic reason, don’t limit my freedoms because some crazy guy did crazy things…

  • http://twitter.com/AgeNightroad Adrian Lloyd

    I’ve never wanted to facepalm SOOO hard in my life…

    He literally just said “…video games is a bigger problem than guns because video games affect people.” but guns don’t?! I… just… wow…

  • InvaderMig

    Don’t underestimate the power of video games people.  The plastic that video game discs are housed in is pretty hard.  If I chuck one of those things at a persons head enough times I could cause them serious damage.  Chances are though, before I could inflict enough damage I’d get shot by the person I was attacking with a video game.  

    So as you can see by my brilliantly illustrated example, the root cause of gun violence in this case, as in all cases was a video game.  Think about that before you demonize this hero.

  • RBHgamer

    I was just watching the movie “Pirate Radio” the other night… and the old adage: nothing is new  comes to mind.  In the early 60′s parliment went after a ship anchored just over 5 miles off the shore of England that was the only broadcaster of Rock and Roll in England.  No broadcaster in England was allowed to play rock They did nothing illegal but the ministers of government were absolutely certain that rock music was also worse than guns. 

  • DosTacos

    If he would get his head out of his, well you know, he’d probably see that 90% of the people in his life play some sort of Video/iPhone/iPad/Android/Console Game that could be seen as Violent. Angry Birds? Anyone? Not exactly GTA I know, but still contains a connotation of Violent behavior, squished by angry birds or shot in the face GTA style, what’s the difference, a game death is a game death.

    “They have four children and five grandchildren.” – Quote from Lamar Alexander’s Senate Website

    Bet you every single one of his children and grandchildren have played and/or are playing a video game that he is now trying to Ban. Pffffft, Typical Congressional Hypocrisy! Monitor your OWN family FIRST Sen. Alexander and then leave it at that. Don’t need a Nanny State, Thank you!

  • Jado Cast

    Guns don’t kill people, video games kill people . . . wait, what?  90% of our politicians are just ignorant.  The founders to our country must be rolling in their graves with what the modern day politicians have done to our country the past 20 years.  Its just sad an pathetic.  Blaming video games on anything is just stupid.

  • http://twitter.com/cecilandblues Anthony Botz

    I think this dude’s conversational grammar ~are~ a bigger problem than Video Games.

  • http://twitter.com/davidthegreater davidthegreater

    What you have to consider about his comments is that you can almost audibly hear him thinking “quick, don’t piss off the NRA, don’t piss off the NRA”. The NRA maintains there’s a violence problem in media, and as a Red senator he’ll tow that line publicly, at least enough to avoid the wrath of the NRA.

    The above should not be construed to say that the Blue politicians are making any more sense in their arguments against guns (AWBs and magazine capacity limits are a joke: see, California), but both sides have their public positions at this point and they are sticking to them regardless of how absurd they might be.

    The point that I think most people are missing is his conclusion, namely that we’re limited in what we can do by the first and second amendment about either “issue” (even if we wanted to do something), which sounds to me like politician-speak for “yeah…don’t expect us to do anything substantive about any of this”.

    Which is roughly what we want, no?

    I mean let’s just look at things realistically for a second, it certainly seems that only anti-gun bills have any traction right now federally given that there are actually bills being introduced to the house and senate with regards to guns and hearings are being held. However I haven’t seen anyone even proposing anything concrete with regards to videogames, much less writing anything down and suggesting it be law. Lot of talking, but if people were actually serious about it we would not only see hearings about violence in media, and we would also see bills, no matter how vague they might initially be.

    Thus my prediction is that federally videogames is a non-starter.

    But Yee? He’s worth worrying about.

    Blue politicians in CA routinely thumb their nose at the courts when their laws are struck down (usually by proposing a functionally identical law the next year) so given a Blue supermajority in CA he very well might try something with regards to videogames again.

  • DoctorOverlord

    Anyone remember how Rap and before that Heavy Metal and before that the very first Rock & Roll songs were supposed to be causing teen depravity and violence?      Remember why they censored classic Bugs Bunny cartoons because they thought it would be causing violence in children?

    Obviously politicians and the media don’t remember much history because they are just repeating the same tune they have been using for decades.  

    Scapegoats are easy and evoke an emotional response rather than one based on reason.  And every single older generation feel threatened by the entertainment choices of the generation that comes after it.   

  • http://twitter.com/Thaguf Thaguf

    (Arnold Impersonation) BULLSHIT

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=768114174 Steve Zagar

    This is why we need freaking term limits in all branches of government.

  • Ravenstorm

    Hamburgers are a bigger problem than senators. But at least they taste good. The senators just stink.

  • http://www.facebook.com/MulletManJeff Jeff Canafax

    My Solution

    Make Guns illegal to be owned by anybody that doesn’t pass a basic mental health exam/ intelligence test.

    And upon purchase or so called “Violent” video games make the customer complete a basic quiz over the ESRB guidelines and content of the video game being purchased. 

    Sample Questions:
    What Age Group Are Games Rated “M” By The ESRB  Targeted Towards?
    What Types Of Content In This Game Warrants It’s Rating Of “M”?
    Do You Realize There Are Depictions Of Heads Exploding As Bullets Rip Through The Skull Of The Players Character Or Other Enemy Characters?
    Do You Have Any Objections To Visualizations Of This Manner? 
    Are You Aware There May Be Sexual Content Or Nudity Portrayed In This Title?
    Do You Have Any Objections To Depictions of Decapitation By Ripping The Head And Spinal Cord By Hand?

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
Take a Poll

What Is Your Most Anticipated MMO?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Monday
6 pst

The Republic

Star Wars The Old Republic

Tuesday
9:30 pst

After Dark

Live Call In Show

n/a

Monty's Minute

Have Questions? He Has Answers

Wednesday
3 pst

OMGLOL

League Of Legends Drama

6 pst

Guildcast

Guild Wars 2

8 pst

Klaus & Squirrel

Gameplay Duo

Thursday
8 pst

Legendary

World of WarCraft

Friday
3 pst

TWIMMO

This Week In MMO



TOP GAMES
Guild Wars 2 MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Arenanet
Metacritic Score: 90
The Elder Scrolls Online MMORPG News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Zenimax
Metacritic Score: n/a
World of Warcraft MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Blizzard
Metacritic Score: 82
SWTOR MMO News
Genre: MMORPG SciFi
Developer: Bioware
Metacritic Score: 85
League of Legends News
Genre: MOBA
Developer: Riot
Metacritic Score: 78