Blizzard fire Warlock Developer


Written by: (@oliviadgrace) | October 26, 2012 1:01 pm

Blizzard fire Warlock Developer
39 Comments

In a shocking move, World of Warcraft developers Activision Blizzard have fired one of their class development team, Xelnath, the man credited with revamping the Warlock class for Mists of Pandaria.

Prior to Mists, the Warlock was one of the least played classes, languishing a country mile behind others for everything but certain arena compositions, where Affliction’s DoT damage remained strong. But its complicated playstyle and slow ramp-up times made it an unpopular class when compared to its burst-heavy brothers and sisters.

Revamping it for Mists of Pandaria was no mean feat, the class was totally reworked, many key mechanics replaced, new energy generation systems implemented for all specs, and spells added and removed. While a team is always in place for such tasks, a key, even leading member of that team was Xelnath.

Xelnath is lauded as the developer who put the fun back into the warlock spec, and as the guy who designed the green fire quests leading warlocks into Black Temple which we discussed in Legendary Episodes 98 and 97.

But what exactly triggered his dismissal? According to a forum post made by the man himself, it was a leak, and some unprofessional behavior:

“Yesterday, I said some very disrespectful and selfish things about the class design team at Blizzard. They decided as a team that Cataclysm was the right spell to go with for Destruction, but in my pride, I made it about myself. I felt powerless to influence the meeting and took out my frustration publicly.

That has led to a series of correct decisions on the part of the Blizzard, as a game designer does not speak for the company and doing so, especially in a negative light about the team he works with everyday is extremely destructive to team cohesion.

I am no longer with Blizzard and I believe this was the right call for both of us.

Best Wishes,
Alex B.”

And what were the unprofessional things he said? Well, a search through recent posts on those same forums, where he was known to share details of warlock changes and communicate Blizzard’s intentions, reveals only one which could have given rise to issues, which Xelnath later confirmed was the problem:

“Also, this is probably the last burst of Class Design work that I’m going to be doing for a while. I burned too much political capital getting Cataclysm through to remain viable in my position. Chaos Bolt will be getting a damage nerf to reduce its Arena viability soon and I will be focusing on other aspects of game design.”

What’s the issue with this post? Well, the Chaos Bolt nerf hadn’t yet been announced, and the expression of burning through political capital could be seen as critical of the development team. As he added:

“I should never have mentioned the Chaos Bolt nerf until it was datamined. That alone is grounds for termination and I did so in a resentful way that made Blizzard look bad.”

Various tribute threads have sprung up on the US and EU forums, and while Blizzard certainly had their reasons, it’s a shame to see someone who’s turned a class around leave the game behind. What do you think? Should he have been fired? Was there likely more going on that we don’t know about?


  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=613400106 Francois Brisson

    Fired for no reason, Blizzard being “politically correct” to calm the sheep down and keep them happy.

  • http://twitter.com/protoskull Proto

    Trion should hire him to work on Cleric DPS ^^

    • http://twitter.com/RiftOvercast RIFT Overcast

      Agreed! Trion, get this guy for Storm Legion!

    • http://www.facebook.com/mary.holly1 Mary Holly

      Agreed… Hope Trion or another good company picks him up.  The ‘lock changes are one of the only reasons I have bothered with MoP.   

  • Clifford Dutka

    210 GameBreaker coins says Bethesda picks him up, seriously fighting with each other over game design? Rather then firing him why doesn’t Blizzard fix there corporate culture?

  • Morturion

    So he did a good job on Warlocks and then they fired him because of a slip of the tongue during a previous expansion ?

    • http://twitter.com/Zedris Zedris

      did you even read the article? because it doesn’t seem like it.

      • Morturion

        I did, but possibly misunderstood a few things. Somebody just told me that cataclysm is a new warlock spell appearently, while I thought they meant the expansion, so yeah…

  • http://twitter.com/NaamahNeko Anna

    Perhaps Blizzard didn’t like the implication that they, like every other organization with more than 1 person, has politics? 

    On the one hand, leaks are bad. We all know why NDAs exist. But I’m going to guess that his statement was completely accurate, and he has no friends left at Blizzard, because I can’t see Metzen, Ghostcrawler, or Bashiok (doubly so) getting fired for leaking a nerf everyone saw coming. Disciplined, certainly, pulled back into the attic until they take corporate sensitivity training, most likely. But fired?  We’ve seen employees issue contradictory Blue posts that sometimes make people think certain CLASSES will be useless, and they just issue an apology and four hours later are tweeting status updates.

  • Chuchirn

    Seems senseless with the current information that we have. However, with these sort of issues there is always more to it then is originally let on. It’s possible that this could of been coming for some time and that this was either the last straw or a reason to push him out. Either way it is regrettable that someone lost their job over something that should of been handled privately and very well could of been used to strengthen the personal connections within the blizzard development team. Just an overall breakdown in the stone facade that is blizzard and very likely means there are more internal struggles going on behind the scenes that have yet to go public. Personally I would not be surprised if more people are quietly let go over this incident as there must of been a breakdown somewhere to allow him to feel the way that he did.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1430932552 Troy Johnson

    Alex being fired is horse shit and blizzard knows it

  • Edd Todd

    Anyone who thinks he was only fired for the comment on the forums he made doesn’t realize that there was probably much more behind the scenes problems with working with him as a person. He has great ideas no doubt but corporations have fired people for less things before. 

  • Deffizzle

    I work for a company thats traded on wall st. and we pander to the shareholders.  That is why he was fired.  Maybe he would get a slap on the wrist for calling out his team publicly but it all comes down to the leak, its kinda the same reason I wont mention where I work.  They look at it an say putting out info before it goes live an its consequences financially is how all these companies look at it. I luv WoW but its soul purpose is to make $$$.  So its setting an examples to its employees about effing w/ the NDA.

  • balen arenas

    There has to be something else besides this that he was let go for.

  • 73igg

    The lock changes are fucking horrible… my lock in cata was my favorite class to play and now it’s shit. I think firing him was well deserved but definitely for the wrong reason.

    • http://twitter.com/AnesthesiaOlogy Josh E

      I thought the way they redid the lock in Cataclysm sucked. It was so much better beforehand. I don’t play WoW anymore, and I don’t have any respect for Blizzard as a gave developer anymore, but I think it would have been hard to come up with any decisions worse than the ones made about the class leading into Cata.

  • http://twitter.com/rigo8582 Rigo Contreras

    If this was isolated incident I don’t think he should be fired. But if he’s had issues working with others being a problem in the workplace then I can see it being justified.

  • http://twitter.com/NerdnGeekInc Raven Frosth

    These days you can get fired for anything, Looking at someone the wrong will get you fired, and what did he leak, I think he got fired way before he said anything on forums.  It’s activision/blizzard they care as much about their employees as they do about their rehashed content in the game.

  • http://www.facebook.com/sigmapsicharlie Stephen C

    No.  Blizzard as company is a pretty damn mediocre developer now.  al they care ablout is money and not their players.  If only they had the passion ArenaNet has for their games.  Guild Wars 2is such a leap forward in the genre, at this point noone will ever make an MMO as complete as GW2, unless Bethesda has something hidden up their sleeves with TESO (but I doubt it).

    • Nick Bryer

       omg get over GW2. Wow is a 10 year old game. Stop comparing the two. Blizzard is a mediocre developer? That statement is also laughable all the way to the bank. I’m pretty sure every developer would love to share the same success blizzard has had with such “medicore” development…

      • http://www.facebook.com/obi.lipnik David Lipnik

        I’m not trying to be a dick or anything, but please, do think of what you’re saying… You’re justifying their tyrant and aggressive business model…  you and defensive people like you are the charcoal for their steam engine that’s had it’s wheels blocked for many years. It’s public – they don’t treat their employees too well and lets be honest, their 9 year old game was mediocre 6 years ago and already pretty sh-t 3 years ago… They keep making bad and worse design decisions, letting business analysts run their game (it’s like selling your child into prostitution!.. if they, of course, still care for their game…) and don’t care whatsoever for their community, as long as enough of people keep paying… That is their only (and yours too apparently…) criteria of success.

        I get it, you like the game, all your friends still play it and you just cant let all your years spent on this god damng grind go to waste… but why, for f- sake, would you defend them? 

        And FYI, making money isn’t the point of these companies… Devs making games that bring money for the publisher is a necessity – not the point.. Their point is supposed to be to make games. THE MANs point is to take your money…

    • ReAlIzEr

      It might seem that way, only because the changes made to the game have been over a long period of time rather then a whole new game all at once.  And pending on how things are going, feels like they are ramping up the game to keep pace with all the new games coming out.

  • http://twitter.com/kirzanSix Michael Coulombe

    Yes, he should have been fired. Companies with secrets as valuable as Blizzard’s, don’t mess around when it comes to NDAs. Hell, even the smaller companies don’t mess around with NDAs. When your company’s secrets is what keeps you in business, then yeah, fire someone who does a leak, or security breach.

    I’ve been working under NDA for 5 years. I’ve seen people get fired for accessing their personal e-mail at the wrong place. He leaked development plans.

    “Yeah but he was so good!” Yeah but he wasn’t a visionary either. There are thousands of designers coming out of institutions, ready to prove themselves. There are probably hundreds of designers currently working for a company, ready to be head-hunted.

    Why they kept him would be a better question, assuming they had kept him.

  • http://twitter.com/Deadalon Deadalon

    Well… least played class is now powning all meters by miles with zero skills… Not that BLizzard would fire a person that manages to screw things in that sense since Balance is least of their interests….

  • http://www.darkapocalypse.net Edwin Perello

    Quite frankly it looks like the rest of the Blizzard team is pissed off warlocks finally have someone championing them in a positive way and now they want him gone.

  • http://www.nexusdevelopment.org/ TheDragonfiend

    Hmmm i liked warlock back in the day it was the only spellcaster i could stand… if he bumped it back up then good for him.

    Honestly at least his work wasnt in vein.

  • http://twitter.com/Velidra Velidra

    Not to mention, by announcing the CB nerf, he was breaking NDA. That’s kind of big. Like. Really big.

  • http://www.facebook.com/knerickson Kaleb Erickson

    At least he broke the pride streak and recognized his fault and the appropriate action.  We all break down and vent, you must choose your words and where you say them wisely though.  

  • http://twitter.com/AnesthesiaOlogy Josh E

    ANet should snag him and let him revamp elementalists.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_F6AZP42EYWGF5ZRW7FRIRNFDG4 Johnny Bravo

    We need a guy like this as a politician. He does great work, the whole company screws up (blizzard try nerfing something besides the class that was always the weakest till recently). And then admitted a screw up openly. Hey Alex could be the first honest politician. he’s get my vote. and as for NDA and keeping secrets, They were going to wait till it was datamined……That’s kind of assinie isn’t it. You were going to leak it anyways and most likely on the first day of ptr (news travels faster than air about class changes). I’d expect this of a typical big company like blizzard where the worker pool is like a sweatshop of talent. I think this has the musings of Ghostcrawler and Bashiok behind it. Those two have always been power hungry (read their twitter posts, its like they think they are kings or some such, One post had me going who do they think they are The Skulls or such?). I hope Trion or Anet does pick alex up and lets him and his creative abilities run wild and reshape whatever game or class he works on. good luck Alex, and thank you for making my lock after so many years not feel like the group let down. cheers mate!

  • ReAlIzEr

    “Loose lips sink ships” is the phrase, and its 100% true.

    To be “fired” from a company that you have worked for over a long period of time, basicly says you did something seriously wrong and the attention of the boss / owner(s) is now facing your way.  He was fired because of ..::several::.. reasons and most of them are around how he treated people (which includes the company as a whole).  The moment you speak “negative” about the company you work for, in any way, to the public, and they find out about it, is grounds for dismissal on the spot, for ALL companys based on the contract you have with them. It might be worded differently but its usually there. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/lyndra.bludrunk Luke Johnson

    hell no, this guy made me play my first toon i made again… i love him, i want him… i… need… him…
     

    • http://twitter.com/dularr Dularr

      I hear you, haven’t played my affic warlock since the first half of LK.  That poor toon has be relegated to ore and herb farming. Why did he have to shoot his mouth off on at a third party site. 

  • MissBegotten

    Well thanks for the notice to the nerf.  The whole of this expac was fun to start but there are too many things that just haven’t worked me up… except for the playablity of my Warlock.  I will agree that since the beginning of Cata, she’s been on the shelf since the ‘kick’ she had was removed.  Knowing that it will be nerfed again just adds to my disappointment overall.  I only paid for 3 months to see what happens, but it seems that the nerf probably will be included by the time of my renewal, so I’ll be going back to GW2 until the next go around.

    Hate to see the guy lose him job, I can understand why, but he did a great service to all Warlocks before he left.  Again, thanks for this snipit of information.

  • favella luv

    Thanks to Dr.Zabaza for bringing back my lover, my lover left  me for my best friend until i saw Dr.Zabaza that help me bring him back to me. if you are in any kind of problem please contact Dr.Zabaza on his email address on zabazalogan@yahoo.com or call Dr.Zabaza on his personal phone number on +2348182620374 for any help.

    Keyla

  • joe stallion

    Some other companies should grab him cos he know how to make a fun gameplay.

  • http://twitter.com/Oledurty J. Johnston

    I’ll bet there was more going on behind the scenes than just the 1 post. Who knows what the real details of the matter are. I believe firing is a lil excessive if it was only this post and nothing more. Seems as though he turned around the warlock class for Blizzard and to pride in his work and for standing his ground, (pehaps improper fashion albeit), he gets canned with no previous slights or warnings?
     I guess thou shalt not anger the dev team that hatches Deathwing.  

    With his talent i’m sure he’ll find more work. The mmo industry can use alot more forward thinkers and ppl not afraid to take a chance.

     Best wishes to ya Xelnath!  “I got a fever… and the only prescription, is more DOTS!” 

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/Z36GPOU3Q2QIQYBIDVNQAVGNGE Raul

    I know I’m i’m totally guessing here,
    but His inflammatory and unprofessional post 
    was probably a built-up reaction to the environment 
    -and people He worked with.

    For what it’s worth,
    A$$hats that fix broken Classes > 
    A$$hats that fire competent designers 
    that voice dissenting opinions, and leak “important details”.

    Too bad They have to choose between the 2.

  • Ethan Baird

    As someone who often finds himself at odds with my coworkers, I would imagine a post like that was simply the tip of the iceberg.  One of the most difficult dichotomies is that many small shops know and see that passionate arguments between coworkers about the product is indicative of a healthy environment.  Although not always the case, larger companies often do everything they can to avoid conflict and favor a “yes sir” attitude from their staff.

    I would think that Blizzard would have learned, but so it goes.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
Take a Poll

What Is Your Most Anticipated MMO?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Monday
6 pst

The Republic

Star Wars The Old Republic

Tuesday
9:30 pst

After Dark

Live Call In Show

n/a

Monty's Minute

Have Questions? He Has Answers

Wednesday
3 pst

OMGLOL

League Of Legends Drama

6 pst

Guildcast

Guild Wars 2

8 pst

Klaus & Squirrel

Gameplay Duo

Thursday
8 pst

Legendary

World of WarCraft

Friday
3 pst

TWIMMO

This Week In MMO



TOP GAMES
Guild Wars 2 MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Arenanet
Metacritic Score: 90
The Elder Scrolls Online MMORPG News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Zenimax
Metacritic Score: n/a
World of Warcraft MMO News
Genre: MMORPG Fantasy
Developer: Blizzard
Metacritic Score: 82
SWTOR MMO News
Genre: MMORPG SciFi
Developer: Bioware
Metacritic Score: 85
League of Legends News
Genre: MOBA
Developer: Riot
Metacritic Score: 78